On their classic debut album, New Zealand quartet Straitjacket Fits blended the Chills’ achingly beautiful melodic sensibilities with Sonic Youth’s soaring drone science. The result was a distinctive hybrid that doesn’t owe too much to either band. In the esteemed Flying Nun tradition, guitarists/vocalists Shayne Carter and Andrew Brough (who passed away in 2020) write exquisitely crafted songs that stick in your mind forever—well, that at least holds true for me, so far.
Straitjacket Fits’ best songs pierce the soul with the bittersweetness of the human condition. Carter’s tear-streaked voice casually floats over the glorious din, verging on melodrama, but always avoiding it. Carter and Brough wrote like sensitive poets, but never made you cringe. Some choice lines: “Your words feel homesick/Watch them flounder in mid air”; “Your skin crawls to escape my hand”; “Her speeding, her freedom’s what’s appealing to me/To stop her in her tracks/Match an act with flat tactics of attack.”
Some of these songs are so breathtaking (especially “Hail,” “She Speeds,” “Dead Heat,” and “Fabulous Things”), I am tempted to base religions on them. “Sparkle That Shines” (which appeared on the UK and US versions, but not on the original NZ release) and “Fabulous Things” are Brough tunes that capture his magically delicate touch; his melodies are paradoxically fragile, yet built to last for eternity. He would go on to pen even greater songs on 1990’s Melt such as “Down In Splendour” and “Such A Daze.” I do wish the Fits had given Brough more real estate on their records… or perhaps he just wasn’t that prolific. Whatever the case, more of Brough’s genius tunesmithery would’ve been nice.
When I listen to Hail, I feel a holy quiver—except when the sugary, unnecessary cover of Leonard Cohen’s “So Long, Marianne” is playing—and I am convinced that Shayne Carter and Andrew Brough were two of the greatest songwriters in rock history. Yet they’re not even in the conversation when that topic arises. And that’s just not right. -Buckley Mayfield
Located in Seattle’s Fremont neighborhood, Jive Time is always looking to buy your unwanted records (provided they are in good condition) or offer credit for trade. We also buy record collections.
